
By Doc Smith, Eagles In Leadership
March 23, 2026
Every pastor has walked into that church—a spiritual hostage crisis. Worship feels obligatory, decisions flow from one domineering voice, and fear hangs thicker than incense. I’ve consulted thriving American and global churches reduced to whispers by a local Faith Community Bully. Often a loud, weaponized woman. Sometimes a grumpy, controlling man. Always a Goliath.
Remember Israel’s army in the Valley of Elah? King Saul’s soldiers trembled before Goliath and his four brothers (1 Samuel 17:1-11). Paralyzed. The people of God, held captive. This drama repeats in pews today. Through decades of church consulting, I’ve identified five groups in every bullied faith community. Spot them. Understand them. And watch God raise a David to deliver.
1. The Conqueror (Goliath Himself)
The self-crowned tyrant who seized control through manipulation, tenure, or unchecked influence. They rule with an iron fist—barking orders, hoarding decisions, crushing dissent. Like Diotrephes, who “loved to have preeminence” and maliciously gossiped about apostolic brothers (3 John 1:9-10).
Tactic: Intimidation. They turn God’s house into their fiefdom. Growth stalls. Joy dies. Goliath defied Israel’s armies 40 days (1 Samuel 17:16). Conquerors defy God’s purposes just as long.
2. The Captives (Saul’s Trembling Army)
The silent majority—good sheep frozen in fear. They “keep heads down,” gripe in parking lots, but never confront. Like Saul’s 30,000 soldiers quaking before the giant (1 Samuel 17:11). They love Jesus but dread the bully’s backlash.
Motive: Survival. “Don’t rock the boat.” They stay, but the church starves.
3. The Collaborators (Saul’s Inner Circle)
Opportunists cozying up to the Conqueror for safety or scraps. They nod in meetings, amplify the bully’s agenda, rat out dissenters. Think Saul’s servants who enabled his paranoia (1 Samuel 18:6-9) or Ahithophel advising Absalom’s coup (2 Samuel 15-17). Covert or overt, they enable tyranny.
Reward: Protection. Cost: Compromise. Their enabling extends the siege.
4. The Critics (Muttering Soldiers)
Brave souls who dislike the bully and voice it—but cautiously. They’re Saul’s men grumbling against Goliath without slinging stones (1 Samuel 17:24-25). Like Korah’s faction, who murmured against Moses but stopped short of full rebellion (Numbers 16:1-3). Right instinct, incomplete action.
Limit: Fear of fallout. They expose wounds but can’t heal them.
5. The Challenger (David, the Deliverer)
God’s outsider—often young, fresh-eyed, zero tolerance for sacred cows. David’s brothers sneered, “Why have you come down?” (1 Samuel 17:28). He saw Goliath defying the armies of the living God. The true Challenger arrives with faith, strategy, and a slingshot.
Two paths:
- Wise David: Prays, gathers intel, builds quiet allies, confronts biblically, restores peace + growth (1 Samuel 17:32-51).
- Foolish Challenger: Charges hot-headed, loses, leaves chaos.
Jesus was the ultimate Challenger, flipping temple tables on religious bullies (John 2:13-16). Churches explode post-deliverance.
Check out Bryson Gray’s new video if you want some encouragement!
Your Church in the Valley of Elah
Inventory your people:
- Pastors: Call Captives to courage. Expose Collaborators. Empower Critics. Pray for your David.
- Challengers: Fast. Study 1 Samuel 17. Get counsel (Proverbs 15:22). Confront with grace + truth—not just skirmish, but victory.
- All: Goliath mocked and his four brothers stood behind him. Bullies rarely stand alone. Dismantle the network.
The Conqueror isn’t invincible. One smooth stone of obedience, and the giant falls (1 Samuel 17:49-50). Who’s your David? God delights in raising them.
Which of the 5 are you? Comment below. Subscribe for leadership tools at EaglesInLeadership.org. Share if you’ve seen freedom after a bully fell.
Doc’s newest book:
Your Travel Guide To The New Testament
(Understanding the Story Lines In Each Book)

What People Are Saying:
Mike Jimenez, MDiv. Dr. Smith has crafted a masterpiece that brings the New Testament to life. A must-read for anyone seeking to unlock the Word of God. A true game-changer for Bible study, providing a clear and engaging guide to the New Testament.
Pastor Ronnie Abubakkar How I wish I had this in my hands during my seminary days. Well written and theologically sound. This book is not only for pastors and seminary students but to all who are a serious student of the Word of God. It is clear, concise and easy to understand truth with practical application for everyday life. I’m very honored to be asked by my good friend Dr. Matthew Lee Smith in endorsing his work of love. Pick a copy and be blessed and encouraged!
You can get your copy at:
Get your copy here: https://books.by/doc-smith
(Also available on Amazon) https://amzn.to/4nULk3i
It sure would would make a great gift!
(Sure you can share this and help me get the word out!)
You can find Doc on:
* Facebook: Eagles In Leadership or Matthew Lee Smith
* X: @drmattphd
* LinkedIn: Eagles In Leadership
* Instagram: : EaglesInLeadership














